The Curious Peanut goes Whiskey Tastin’
The other night I was invited to a Bushmills whiskey dinner at a posh new Boston restaurant called Post 390. Although I’m not a big fan of whiskey, I was curious to learn more about this spirit that we call Bourbon. I confess I also was eager to try the restaurant. Such is the life of a food writer.
Bushmills is the oldest distillery in Ireland, having been founded over 400 years ago in the village of Bushmill (population 1,500). The distillery prides itself on making whiskey from 100 percent malted barley, versus a mixture of malted and unmalted barley. Malting is a process whereby grains (in this case, barley) are soaked in water until they germinate and then the germination process is quickly halted through drying to prevent the grains from sprouting further. Unlike many distilleries that dry their germinated barley over peat, thus giving the whiskey a strong, smoky flavor, Bushmills uses no peat during the drying process, preferring instead to let the grains’ natural flavors shine through.
Three folks from Bushmill hosted the dinner, including master distiller Colum Egan, a funny, fresh-faced, 40-year-old. Only two other journalists came to the dinner, aside from me, which made me glad I had brought my husband, who was the only other male at dinner aside from Colum.
With the first course of duck-stuffed pot stickers, we sampled the Bushmills Original. At 80 proof, it tasted woody and very fiery. Colum suggested we stir in a few spoonfuls of water into our glass to enhance the whiskey’s aroma and break the pure alcohol surface film, thus making it easier to drink. The water helped.
The process of making whiskey is actually quite simple. The first step is called mashing in which the malted barley grains are pulverized and blended with hot water to create a liquid called wort. Next comes fermentation where yeast is added to the wort to help the sugars convert to alcohol, resulting in a substance called wash. The final step is distillation, whereby the wash is brought to a boil in order to separate out the alcohol. Bushmills distills their whiskey three times, “to try to capture a light and fruity flavor,” says Colum.
The second whiskey to arrive, along with a gorgeous heap of tuna tartar, was the 7-year-old Black Bush. It was deep amber in color and perfumed with caramel, thanks to the sweet sherry oak barrels it had been stored in. I took a sip. Alas, I thought it tasted kind of like the first whiskey.
For our third whiskey, we sampled 10 Year, a 30-year-old single malt made from 100 percent malted barley that isn’t blended. “This is the kind of whiskey that you drink when you’re chilling at home,” said Colum, “when the kids and wife are in bed, it’s cold outside, and you’re in front of a roaring fire.” How romantic I thought. I took a taste. The whiskey was smooth, but still kind of burned and had an aftertaste of kindling, not the “warm milk chocolate running down your throat,” that Colum had described. I ate my warm grilled oysters topped with linguica, disappointed in myself for not achieving that Willy Wonka moment.
Next up was the 16 Year served with mashed potatoes and a slab of veal, beef, and pork meatloaf stuffed with fontina cheese. Here was a chance to redeem myself. The whiskey had been carefully aged in Bourbon- and Olorosso sherry-seasoned casks, which Colum said would lend flavors of vanilla and almonds. It was then aged for several months in Port wine barrels to impart a fruity sweetness. I took a swallow of the whiskey and then another, just to be sure. Sure of what? Sure, that instead of pralines, toffee, and dark chocolate, I tasted little more than alcohol? Oh, dear.
Our last whiskey of the night was the 21 Years, rare and made in extremely limited quantities. With a mouthful of flourless chocolate torte, I listened to Colum explain how the whiskey was aged for a minimum of 19 years in Olorosso sherry and Bourbon-seasoned casks before being finished off for two years in Madeira barrels. It was the kind of whiskey Colum said he’d serve on a very special occasion, like the wedding of his offspring. He sniffed the soft brown liquid and took a sip.
“Like a really rich fruit cake,” he said, marveling at the whiskey’s spicy, dried fruit flavors. I love fruit cake. I took a sip, allowing the precious liquid to linger in my mouth while waiting for the special flavors to reveal themselves. I waited. Then I waited a little more, before having another bite of chocolate torte. Whiskey takes time to appreciate. The palate learns more with every tasting. I’m sure I’ll do better next time.








